Type of Research
Social Research – Face to Face interviewing
Mackman Research was commissioned by a Borough Council in Essex to research the use of parks and gardens. In particular the Borough Council wanted to explore the use of parks and gardens by families on low incomes and minority groups. The research process was split into two phases. The first phase sought to audit all Borough Council run parks and gardens in a bid to discover who was using the parks, how frequently and for what purpose they were using the parks. The results of the first phase informed the second phase of the research; this gave way to direct targeting of unemployed (in receipt of benefits) residents.
During the research process a mixed methodology approach combined quantitative statistical representation (of the local population) with qualitative data gathering methods. This mixed methodology approach enabled the researchers to approach all respondents on a face-to-face basis whilst interviewing a total of 816 respondents.
The data gathering process was split into 2 phases. The 1st phase aimed to audit the parks and gardens. This phase set out to record who was using each park and test the theory of low-income non-users. Phase 1 would direct data gathering in phase 2 and enable the research team to directly target those who are not using parks and gardens.
Phase 1 – Parks Audit (Identifying non-users)
Mackman Research designed a structured questionnaire in consultation with our client. The questionnaire asked questions about the respondents park use and included a section that would record demographic information. The researchers were able to record observations about general park use and record spontaneous comments from respondents. A total of 19 parks and gardens in the borough were audited during this 1st phase.
All respondents were approached and introduced to the purpose of the survey by the researcher. Respondents were selected for no other reason than being present in the park. The research team made every effort to interview all park users in each location at the time of our visit. Parks were visited on one weekday and one weekend day.
Phase 2 – Non-user Interviews / Barriers to Use Research
Data gathering commenced face-to-face and door-to-door with unemployed residents (The unemployed and elderly being non-users of the parks).
A structured questionnaire was designed in consultation with our client. The questionnaire was based upon the same questionnaire used during phase 1.
During this stage, data collection was targeted to specific geographical areas of deprivation with high numbers of unemployed residents. It was evident a specific ward had been under-represented in the parks audit phase; therefore our data gathering efforts were focused on this ward. The Borough Council identified specific areas and streets within which contained high frequencies of our target non-park using respondent.
Simple random sampling was employed in order to select streets to target for door-to-door interviewing. Homes were to be targeted for interviews using systematic random sampling, however, this method was not used in specific streets as many residents were not at home, therefore random sampling naturally occurred.
All surveys were anonymous and respondents were notified of this.
Sample Size and Confidence Interval
The phase 1 survey population contained 445 respondents. This figure achieved a 95% confidence level and a +/- 4.64% confidence interval, based upon a total population of 162,000.
371 respondents completed the phase 2 questionnaire, achieving a confidence level of 95% and a confidence interval of +/-5%, of a low-income population of 9,500.
The phase 1 survey consisted of 20 closed questions and one open ended question and the phase 2 survey consisted of 29 closed questions.
TestimonialThe project team delivered a great piece of research. Based on our experience the following qualities were apparent: 1) Flexible: Especially since we adapted the methodology to reach target audience. 2) Question development: The team was positive and constructive in questionnaire design, integrating our local knowledge with their expertise. 3) Approachable: team adopted a collaborative and can do approach. 4) Reporting: was clear and in-depth.
Fiona Foskett – Marketing Officer
It was evidently clear during the phase one data analysis that it was worth exploring other barriers to park and garden use besides low income groups, as there was a high percentage of respondents with a weekly disposable income of less than £100. The unsteady economic climate was also thought to have some influence here.
In 2009, according to the ONS (Office of National Statistics) unemployment had reached the highest rate since 1999, with the number of “workless” households rising to 3.3 million in April – June 2009. Although the East of England was thought to be least affected by this, the recession and unemployment had touched this region too. With 1 in 6 households being “workless” in the UK, unemployment is a key factor in activities of daily life and is therefore thought to directly impact upon recreational activities and leisure time.
“…dropping out of the rhythm of activity that is centred around holding a job leaves people psychologically incapable of maintaining the orientations necessary to utilise the opportunities which becomes available for recreation.” (Roberts: 1970)
The data analysis of the information gathered during the 2nd phase of the research considered many barriers to park use, specifically unemployment, education, background, leisure pursuits, age and disability and security. Minority groups and persons with a disability were found to be proportionately representative of the population.
The parks research has been invaluable to the Borough Council and is thought to be one of a kind. The research has helped identify areas for improvement and informed marketing to help raise awareness of the parks and gardens.
Background Sure Start Hyndburn Children’s Centres offer services, information and advice to families with children aged under five years old,…
Background Baker Tilly is a leading independent firm of accountants and business advisers that specialises in providing an integrated range…
Background Land Rover Monthly magazine is a publication for Land Rover specialists. Land Rover Monthly holds a yearly weekend, 3…
- We have been so impressed with the standard of work delivered by Mackman. They are lovely people who are committed to offering a quality service, and we have found them to be responsive, informed, thorough and personable. The final presentation of results was incredibly well put together, delivered with clarity, and gave us more insight than we had hoped for. We have immediately instructed them to carry out further work for us as it is not often that services exceed your expectations.Recruitment Agency
- It was a great piece of work which confirms feelings we have had about the business and this data is invaluable in substantiating this information. This evidence will help EOS improve and make precise business decisions for the future.Electrical Oil Services Ltd (EOS)
- We try very hard to communicate well with our customers and the information we have gathered from the survey will be invaluable in helping us to refine the way we work. In particular we have really key information to enable us to promote and assist with digital inclusion. We also now have information that will help us to communicate differently according to customer preferences.Greenfields Community Housing
- Eastern Inshore Fisheries and Conservation Authority contacted Mackman with a brief to carry out an awareness campaign. Immediately, we felt that they understood the requirements of the research and they took reasonable time to consider a sound and practical methodology to meet the demands of the project. The research team were easy to talk to, enthusiastic and worked hard to bring the project in on time and to a tight timescale and budget. We were impressed by the final report showing comprehensible results and recommendations. An additional presentation which we requested covered everything we defined in a concise and practical solution. This report is a valuable study: The results have given our organisation a benchmark for future engagement with our key stakeholders, helping Eastern IFCA continue to make an impact on the work we do to sustainably manage inshore fisheries in Lincolnshire, Norfolk and Suffolk. We are looking forward to making the most of the research, to create and deliver a targeted engagement activity programme. I have no hesitation in recommending Mackman; their work is of an extremely high standard and they are a pleasure to work with.Eastern Inshore Fisheries and Conservation Authority
- After meetings with various companies regarding a customer and an employee satisfaction survey, Mackman were chosen. In our initial meetings they showed that they understood our business and what we were trying to achieve. As a company we had never outsourced our customer and employee satisfaction surveys before, or linked the two and wanted to ensure we got it right. We felt confident that Mackman would help us achieve this. I also liked the thought of working with a local company. I felt it would be more cost effective and liked the idea of having a company close to hand in case of any issues. I would not hesitate to work with Mackman again. The staff are friendly and approachable and took the time to understand what we are trying to achieve. They always kept me updated on progress; they are enthusiastic, knowledgeable, have a ‘can-do’ approach and never missed any deadlines set.Specflue
- I found the entire team at Mackman to be driven to achieving the best result for Baker Tilly. I valued their persistence to get the job done. They communicated regularly with me and kept me informed about milestones and possible delays to the project well in advance so I could take appropriate action and ensure the project was kept to schedule. The final report of the results was presented in a clear and easy to understand report. The report is invaluable to us as we use it to determine our marketing approach and plan our business development campaigns for this audience. From the report, we have been successful in gaining many PR opportunities (including front page coverage with the Financial Times). I'd be more than happy to recommend the Mackman Group.Baker Tilly London